Epilogue Wing Fences

Started by Tom Laird, 11, November 2026, 04:21:29 PM

« previous - next »

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Tom Laird

Hi, 
Calling all Epilogue users: I was wondering if you are using or have used wing fences? I am investigating a tendency to tip-stall at the entry to spins and wondered if you saw any difference. 
thanks
Tom

wing fence 1.jpg

wing fence 2.jpg

Keith Jackson

Hi Tom,

Wing fences or turbulator tape will substantially improve the entry into the spin and prevent wing wobble on sharp pull / push outs from vertical.

I did a couple of articles in May and July 2026 RCM&E covering this on my Strato. Also used turbulator tape on my original Leader bp to very good effect.

Hope this helps

Keith

Tom Laird

Hi Keith,
Thank you. I will get my hands on the two issues you mentioned from a friend of mine.
br
Tom

James Fallowfield

#3
Hi Tom,

I took the fences off my Epilogue, if you want to improve stability of the model approaching a stall at spin entry I would use turbulator tape.

Dave Matthias

Hi Tom
I also don't use the fences on my epilogue
And I do find it tricky when approaching a spin especially in a cross wind I've not tried turbulator tape on mine yet but will be getting some to try as i think it may help .

AW2

I have a little experience with wing fences, and found that they did improve roll stability on spin entries, on the models that seemed to need it.
The exact placement along the span didn't seem that critical.
I have almost no experience with turbulator strips,but would like to ask:
Is placement span-wise, and chord-wise, a bit critical?

James Fallowfield

Quote from: Dave Matthias on 11, November 2026, 11:09:50 PMHi Tom
I also don't use the fences on my epilogue
And I do find it tricky when approaching a spin especially in a cross wind I've not tried turbulator tape on mine yet but will be getting some to try as i think it may help .
Quote from: AW2 on 12, November 2026, 04:52:13 PMI have a little experience with wing fences, and found that they did improve roll stability on spin entries, on the models that seemed to need it.
The exact placement along the span didn't seem that critical.
I have almost no experience with turbulator strips,but would like to ask:
Is placement span-wise, and chord-wise, a bit critical?
Around 50mm from the leading edge and parallel with the same. 

Bob Wasson

Evening Alan,

Good to hear from you again.  I hope you are still deriving a lot of fun from practicing the latest schedules.

I am behind the times in relation to the latest contra driven biplanes.  But when I am able, I still like flying my 2m F3A BJ Craft Epilogue.  Fitted with an RS 3-Blade and a Debowski D3 ESC it is far and away the best monoplane 2m F3A set up I have flown. It's only real downside is a tendency to tip stall during landing.  This can be a real U/C wrecker.  Especially if the model is fitted with the original BJ legs that have a well-deserved reputation for brittleness and lack of flexibility.

Having searched AI for the optimum solution, the consensus would appear to be:

# Cover only the outer 35% to 40% of each wing on the top surface only.  Leaving the inner wing bare ensure the wing root stalls before the tips, giving a gentle, straight nose drop warning instead of a vicious snap.
# Place the LE of the tape at 10% to 15% of the local wing cord. Because the Epilogue aerofoil reaches its maximum thickness relatively far forward, placing the strip just ahead of the high point keeps the flow attached during the landing flare.
# Use zig-zag tape of 0.4 mms to 0.5 mms thickness.  Thinner tape will get swallowed by the boundary layer and have no effect.

Even with all of the above, I would caution against trying to stall an Epilogue into the traditional 3-point touchdown.  I have found it much better to try to "fly" it onto the strip for a 2-point touchdown and allowing the tail wheel to settle as the speed drops off.  (I also much preferred the more flexible Falcon landing gear as was strongly recommended by Bondaero).

I hope the above is of some help.  But there are other Forum members, James being one, who are putting in umpteen more flights these days than I am and who can be trusted to offer sound advice.

Best wishes

Bob

Russ Bowey

#8
Going back to the start of the thread. Wing fences are typically used on swept wings to stop the outboard spanwise airflow movement. However, a wing at high alpha as it approaches the stall prior to a spin will have a reverse at the tip where airflow tends to migrate from high pressure on the underside to low pressure on the top. The fence at the tip of an Epilogue wing could well be unbenefical as the two airlflow's will naturally oppose each other anyway...

Turbulators are lovely in theory, but without the benefit of a wind tunnel, will be hard to place in the correct place. They need to activate (energise) the boundary layer just ahead of the separation point, so there is a softer transition from the smooth laminar flow of the boundary layer to separation, by clever use of a slightly turbulent boundary layer. That position could typically be anywhere between 20 - 50% of the chord, in some cases much further aft. Trial & error will get it right, but it wouldn't be easy. If the strip is in the wrong place, it might not have much benefit.

From what I've seen during lots of training sessions, most people try to use ailerons to keep the wings level during very slow speed flight, resulting in the opposite to the desired results, since if a wing drops, aileron input will only increase the AoA of that wing resulting in a quicker 'tip' stall.

Proper use of rudder could well be more effective than either a wing fence or a turbulator strip, especially if either a fence or a strip are placed even slightly in the wrong position.

Bob Wasson

#9
With specific reference to landing approaches, I would agree that, in theory (aileron correction increasing the AoA of the lower wing), rudder correction may be the better option for some airframes.

The specific problem with the Epilogue is that, in plan view, the tip profile is very sharply tapered.  A tip stall on the approach is virtually instantaneous.  Close to the ground, there is no time to correct with either rudder or aileron. 

The safer option is to maintain some airspeed and "fly" an Epilogue on to the deck for a 2 wheeled landing.  After which up elevator could be gradually applied allowing the tailwheel to touch down as groundspeed reduces naturally due to drag.

That approach could save a lot of broken U/C legs and damage to fuselage sides and mountings.

Keith Jackson

Hi Everyone,

Please remember that if you are adding turbulator tape to help with spin entries / square pull outs etc, then as you are flying an aerobatic model, the strips do need to be used on both upper and lower surfaces symmetrically. I proved this out multiple times on my Leader BP. They definitely help getting the model to a stalled condition whilst preventing premature tip stall. Landings are very easy with this model also as a result of the wing fences. Also just to reiterate, the wing fences on my Strato were similarly proved with trial and error. In hindsight, I probably would have opted for turbulator tape instead as fences are a pain when it comes to transportation and wing bags, hence mine were made to be removable. 

Hope this helps

KeithDSCN2808a.jpg

Mike Pole

I have now flown a few Epilogues and only used wing fences on the first one. On the next two that were both acquired from top pilots I heeded their suggestion to omit the fences, I believe to improve snap rolls. I was initially nervous about the potential for tip stalls on landing but I agree with Bob regarding this and always avoid trying to float the plane down to a three pointer, preferring to fly the plane in. If I need to stretch the landing I get some power back on and remain straight and level.
I do however struggle with spin entries (I hope none of the judges are listening!). I always seem to be fighting a premature wing drop with aileron which as Russ has now said is maybe the wrong thing to do. I will therefore order some turbulator tape and experiment with that.

Bob Wasson

The justification given by AI for the recommendation of top wing only for turbulator tape to reduce tip stalling on landing is as follows: "Turbulators on the bottom surface are used on sailpanes to eliminate drag-inducing laminar separation bubbles during high speed cruise.  On an aerobatic model, bottom surface tape adds parasitic drag without improving high angle of attack stall behaviour".

It wouldn't be the first time I have found AI recommendation to be wrong.  Added to which, on an F3A model, I can think of reasons why some additional parasitic drag might even be helpful! (For glider competition flying, as Bill Haley - multiple times UK champion - will confirm, additional drag is counterproductive.)

For these reasons, I would err strongly in favour of following the recommendations of an experienced F3A pilot who we know and trust and who has carried out extensive experiments.

For those wanting to give turbulator tape a go, it would make sense to follow Keith's recommendations.

Tom Laird

Hi,
Thank you everyone who has contributed to the replies. There is a lot to ponder here before I make any changes.
best regards
Tom

Keith Jackson

Hi Tom,

Perhaps best to try a temporary fixing to assess each method? Just mark out exactly where the fences will go, fix a strip of 10 mm wide masking tape over this location and tack the fences into place using cyano. Fly it and see before any permanent fix. Much easier to assess the turbulator tape... In both cases its crucial they are symmetrical and not toe-ing in or out re the model centre line.

I think you'll be surprised how much they do add benefit

Keith