UKF3A Forum

F3A Aerobatics => Competition News => 2025 Competitions and Results => Topic started by: Kevin Caton on 01, March 2025, 02:26:01 PM

Title: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 01, March 2025, 02:26:01 PM
Entries are now open for the UKF3A Championships and F3A World Cup Competition at Buckminster on Saturday 7th & Sunday 8th June 2025.

This will be a combined event as in 2024.

I have attached the World Cup Competition Bulletin for information.

Please note that there will be no "P&F" class for the Championships - this is covered by the World Cup Competition. It is only permitted to enter either the Championships or the World Cup - not both.

On Friday 6th June there will be a UKCAA Classic Aerobatic event on the site until around 1600hrs. We will of course be welcome to attend the UKCAA event as a pilot or spectator, but the field will not be available for F3A use until their event has finished.

Title: Re: UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition - Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 02, March 2025, 07:22:10 AM
Entries

FAI World Cup

Kevin Caton (GBR)
Jim Fallowfield (GBR)
Arthur Silsby (GBR)
Thomas David (GBR)
Matt Hoyland (GBR)
Derk Van der Vecht (NED)
Arnaud Fontaine (FRA)
Dan Workman (GBR)
Javad Aghababazadeh (IRI)
Garry Peacock (GBR)
Brandon Ransley (GBR)
Steve Burgess (GBR)
Pete Madden (GBR)

UKF3A Championships

P Only

Ken Moss
Brian Hoare
Stephen Simm
Gerhard Fehringer
Matthew Smailes
Adrian Harrison
Mike Pole
Peter Scoles
Phil Lewis


Masters

Steve Smithey
Greg Butterworth


Intermediate

Joe Wotton



Clubman

Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 01, May 2025, 09:25:01 PM
Entry list updated.
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 08, May 2025, 02:20:55 PM
Last call for entries to our UKF3A Championships and World Cup competition. I need to close the entries by this Sunday 11th May to assess whether the event is viable.

I have to say that the response to our organisation's premier event is underwhelming. Buckminster is a valuable site and unless we can support it better, other disciplines will happily take our slots. I can't guarantee that the site cafe will be open either as we haven't reached the threshold for it to be worthwhile.

More entries and suggestions on what to do are welcome. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: brandon ransley on 10, May 2025, 01:13:40 PM
I'm in Kevin. I'll send entry early next week. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Phil Lewis on 10, May 2025, 02:08:33 PM
Hi Kevin, I entered on 01/05/2025 but I'm not on the entry list yet, I'm guessing it hasn't been updated yet?

Phil
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 10, May 2025, 05:09:19 PM
Thanks Phil - I've added you now. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 11, May 2025, 10:16:27 AM
Entry numbers are looking healthier now - thanks (and sorry for those I'd missed). The pilots in Intermediate and Masters would appreciate some competition though - so if anyone still wants to enter these classes (and Clubman) please do so.
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Jim on 11, May 2025, 11:14:09 AM
Just entered Kevin
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Mick Broad on 11, May 2025, 05:41:50 PM
Hi Kevin

Ive just been informed that im required elsewhere for the championship weekend.
Appoligies but i will have to withdraw from intermediate . Please arrange refund for this two day event.

Regards
Mick broad
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Joe Wotton on 12, May 2025, 11:57:19 AM
Entered 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Kevin Caton on 15, May 2025, 10:54:45 AM
For the World Cup competition, in common with the other countries that put on these events, we organise lunch (sandwiches, crisps, soft drink) on the field each day and an evening meal (a barbecue type buffet in our case). The payment for these gives us a small surplus which is used to partly offset the cost of running the event - site hire, judging expenses etc.

Our Championships, which of course run in parallel with the World Cup, don't have the meal option on the entry form, so I'd like to ask the Championships entrants if they would also consider taking part in the meal service to make it "one event" (and help our finances). Each lunch is priced at £12.50 and the Saturday evening meal is £25. The lunches are dropped off at the flight line around midday and the evening meal is served from the Flyers' Cafe with the option of relocating to the hangar if the weather isn't good enough to eat outside.

The Flyers' Cafe will also be open on Saturday and Sunday for breakfast and drinks, sandwiches etc until early afternoon. If you would like a cooked breakfast these need to be ordered directly with the cafe staff the day before.

Please let me know if you would like to take the meal options and of course if there is anyone with you who would also like to join in.

You can contact me by any of the usual routes - reply here, email, WhatsApp etc.
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Alan Williams on 21, May 2025, 07:31:16 AM
Hi all,
This is a call for a few volunteers to assist with Judging over the weekend.
I need a couple of WC pilots to help judge the Championship P flights and a couple of Champs P pilots for the Intermediate and Masters.
I hope any volunteer will only have to judge one round, so not too onerous.

Greg has offered his services already so I will gratefully receive an any other offers!

Many thanks

Al.
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Garry Peacock on 21, May 2025, 02:51:21 PM
Happy to help Al. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Alan Williams on 22, May 2025, 07:10:50 AM
Thanks Gary. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Brian Hoare on 22, May 2025, 07:18:24 PM
Hi Alan

I would be happy to judge Masters and the intermediate.

Regards
Brico
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Thomas David on 23, May 2025, 07:27:57 AM
Hi Al,

I'm happy to judge too.

cheers,

Tom
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Alan Williams on 23, May 2025, 03:02:47 PM
Thanks Tom and Brian. 
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Phil Lewis on 05, June 2025, 09:11:57 PM
On Kevin's behalf here is the flight order for the World Cup/UK Championships this weekend.

Any errors spotted please let me know ASAP.

Phil
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Phil Lewis on 08, June 2025, 07:19:15 PM
On Kevin's behalf and much head scratcing here are the combined results gleaned from both Pi's, World Cup first.

Should anyone have any queeries please make contact right away.

Phil
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Phil Lewis on 08, June 2025, 07:41:46 PM
And now Intermediate, Masters and P-25.

Phil
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Mike Pole on 09, June 2025, 08:47:54 AM
Thank you to Kevin, all judges, Phil and all concerned with this weekends Champs and World Cup.
Kazie and I thoroughly enjoyed it even when the wind was outside our 'comfort zone'.
Having seen the forecasts leading up to the weekend it's amazing how it all ran to schedule.
Thank you again,
Mike & Kazie
Title: Re: 06 07 - UKF3A Championships & World Cup Competition, Buckminster 7th & 8th June 2025
Post by: Alan Williams on 10, June 2025, 08:26:37 PM
Below some feedback from Nico and LLaurent. 
I can add that similar comments could be made about the P only flights.
I have also posted this is the judging tab, in case some will not see this thread.

From Nico:
Laurent and I shared our impressions about the flights over the weekend and I think we were generally on the same line.
Don't hesitate to ask other judges on the next competitions to give the team the latest and most accurate tips.

The weather conditions didn't help to go deep into individual flights but we can still take global observations out of it.
Firstly even with these tough conditions pilots did perform on pretty high standards, not reaching top marks as they would do in normal weather but I gave a lot of 8 or 8,5 scores and relatively few bad ones which is a sign of strong and solid backbone of the category here.

The main point I will raise is the ratio distance/sizing of the manoeuvres. Saturday I was not that comfortable appreciating central manoeuvres but trying to get shelter from the rain I was moving my head in and out of the tent. Thing is I did feel the same on Sunday while the tents were away...
To make it short I've arrived at the conclusion that pilots were flying too big, too close.

I know these last years we focused on distance, the sporting code strongly insisting on this criteria. I would say that globally distance is now fine and matches the requirements but we have to come back to this more important rule:
Art. 5.1.8. Marking g)
"Manoeuvres must be performed such that they can be seen clearly by the judges ... If, for some reason within the control of the competitor, a judge is not able to follow the model aircraft through the entire manoeuvre, he has to downgrade the manoeuvre accordingly."
Practically in the P schedule:
- the roll combination after the vertical 9 is too high above our heads to be properly appreciated, it's 6 1/4 rolls to assess on horizontal/vertical position which requires to be clearly seen.
- the spin entry starts with a nose-up attitude that you can not see when it's just above your head.
- the figure S finishes by a 1/4 roll integrated. Who has been able to see the integration on this grey sky? I did really struggle with that.
Practically in the F schedule:
- first manoeuvre, square loop on corner, hard to see the integration at the top.
- roll combination: same as in the P.
- half loop: basically there's not enough room left to size it accordingly to the proportion of the manoeuvres requirements but on top of this seeing the integration of the half loop was a challenge.

Art 5B. 11. Size of the manoeuvre
It costs up to 1 point per manoeuvre, when a manoeuvre is too big in the manoeuvring zone but also when you compare a manoeuvre to the others.
Few illustrations in the P:
- The half cloverleaf doesn't need 2 full size loops with an exit barely above their tops.
- The comet when finishing at the centre creates an overlap with the S and then costs 1 point to each manoeuvre.
In the F I will just talk about the vertical 8:
- What is the point of going that high?
- It's a long manoeuvre, it's boring to judge, why would you let too much time to the judge to think about the radii differences on the 8 angles plus positions and roll rates of the many rolls and part rolls?
- Plus you expose the model to the wind.
- If your plane is at the expected 175m in depth it means it's above the 300 meters height, I'm sure you don't need that much space to perform a nice looking 8.
- I've seen many different shapes of squares and lots of top squares bigger than the lower ones which then looked like rectangles.

Then about distance: Art 5B.10.
It's clearly said that the main criterion is visibility. If you can't quickly downsize please find a compromise with the distance, fly where it's comfortable to fly for you and easy to see for the judge and progressively get closer downsizing the flights.
Check how much time you need to run a whole schedule and see if reducing the size would give you more comfort to shape, centre, leave time and space to execute a proper portion of straight line between manoeuvres?
Could downsizing allow to reduce the speed considering that high speed makes any mistake look more obvious and harder to correct?
Could I sneakily add that the flight has to be executed at a constant speed: Art 5B. 9.?

Modern planes can I'm sure accurately perform the schedules at a lower speed, the engines can now deliver more power than needed when needed.
When I'm looking back at the evolution of the schedules over these last 30 years I'm seeing a movement from "ballistic" lines to more complex manoeuvres requiring different skills. To give an example we don't need anymore to get to a high speed to hope that the plane will reach the top of a kind of round loop, we now need control.
Apart the distance the sporting code doesn't give measurements, radii sizes, doesn't impose a specific speed but asks for precision, accuracy and harmony, it's not a race. A different rhythm has to be found for each manoeuvre depending on its location, that's where in my opinion we see the pilot's style and personality.

Then, if during a flight the pilot's neck can't go further back without moving the shoulders backward the manoeuvre is more than probably performed too high or too big. If the caller behind feels the same the caller should probably say something and discuss it during the debrief after the flight.

So, that's it basically, work on the ratio size, distance and speed. Everyone should find more comfort, especially in rough conditions.

Couple of things before leaving:
- If the definition of a snap is pretty much about what a snap isn't, we need to have a noticeable kind of explosive moment of something to make us think it's not a quick roll or a barrel roll. Even if physically the plane does stall, we have to see something to score it.
- A humpty-bump would look easy but generally doesn't score well because entry, top and exit have to have the same radii. If the pilot wants a big round top keep in mind that the entry and especially the exit have to match, when I say especially the exit it's because at the end the exit is often too tight compared to the top. Keep in mind that the Aresti is a visual code, not an accurate drawing of the manoeuvre. On the paper sheet there's no round corners on the squares, there's no round entry and exit on the humpty-bumps but there are in the sky. Radii have to be the same and they are compared to the previous one within the same manoeuvre.
- When there is a change in direction of rolls or part rolls it has to be immediate. With the strong wind facing the planes I've seen in the rolls combinations some pilots realising that the plane did not as usual reach the center of the flying area and then kept the plane on knife-edge position to roll on the center. Please don't wait and bounce, a judge will notice the wait but not especially the flag way under the plane and I personally would penalise the wait more than the position.
- Finally, one last but not least point: geometry is the main judging criteria, we've discussed it a lot about shapes and sizing, I would add a reminder about the importance of having the rolls and part rolls properly centred in their portions of straight lines within the manoeuvres. A common mistake is to see these elements coming too late, mostly once the center is passed and it causes a clash with the end/exit of the line. For a judge it's a kind of easy mistake to catch, especially at the end of the line more than at the beginning... Please take care of it, it's more than a detail, it's way too many points lost because of this.